UNIVERSAL RIFT RECORDS
Back to News
NewsStars and galaxies

A Star’s X-ray Swings May Explain Changing Helium Escape on LHS 1140 b

An arXiv study links short-term X-ray variability from the star LHS 1140 to changes in helium escaping from its rocky, habitable-zone planet. The proposed explanation still needs simultaneous observations to be tested.

Maya EllisonNov 14, 2026 · 5 min read
Variable X-ray flux tied to helium escape on LHS 1140b
AI-generated illustration.

A new study proposes that changes in X-ray output from the star LHS 1140 can help explain why helium escaping from its rocky, habitable-zone planet, LHS 1140 b, has varied over time. The work by Collin Cherubim, Tim Cunningham and Jason A. Dittmann was posted to arXiv on September 25, 2026, and is based in part on an 18-hour observation of the star with the XMM-Newton space telescope in 2026. Orbital Wire reported on the study on November 12. The proposed link is not yet confirmed: the authors say coordinated observations are needed to test it.

What the observations found

Orbital Wire reported that researchers used XMM-Newton to collect X-ray and ultraviolet measurements of LHS 1140 during an 18-hour observing window in 2026. They were investigating whether changes in the star’s high-energy radiation could account for changes in helium absorption observed during transits—events in which the planet passes in front of its star from our viewpoint.

The measured X-ray flux varied, with a maximum-to-minimum ratio reported as Fmax/Fmin = 8.5+9.4−4.4. No variability was detected in ultraviolet or visible flux during that window. XUV is shorthand for X-ray and extreme-ultraviolet radiation, high-energy light that can affect a planet’s upper atmosphere.

The authors compared models with observations from 2018 and 2026. Although the total X-ray flux measured in 2026 matched the 2018 measurement, the earlier observation could not detect the level of short-term variability seen in 2026. According to Orbital Wire, the models fit both datasets. The researchers favor short-term XUV variation and/or small flares over long-term changes in XUV output as a better explanation for the changing helium signal.

Why the result matters

Helium escaping from a planet’s upper atmosphere offers researchers a way to study how that atmosphere responds to radiation from its star. The reported variability matters because it suggests the observed helium signal may change even when the planet’s atmosphere has not simply disappeared. Orbital Wire reported that the helium signal was observed in 2024 but not in 2025. Modeling suggests that moderate changes in stellar high-energy output or upper-atmosphere temperature could make the signal too faint to detect while the atmosphere remains.

That distinction is important: a missing helium absorption signal in one set of observations does not, by itself, establish that a planet has lost its atmosphere. The new study offers a possible mechanism for changes in detectability, not a definitive explanation for every change in the signal.

The broader question is whether rocky planets around small stars can retain atmospheres over long periods. The study describes atmospheric retention on potentially habitable planets around M stars as a central exoplanet-science goal. Such planets can be observed, but prolonged exposure to high-energy radiation may erode their atmospheres. For readers following the search for potentially habitable worlds, LHS 1140 b is a case where repeated observations can reveal not just whether an atmosphere is present, but how it behaves.

The planet and the earlier helium detection

LHS 1140 b is a rocky planet in the habitable zone of its star. The habitable zone is the region where conditions could allow liquid water on a planet’s surface; being in that region does not establish that a planet has surface water or is habitable. Orbital Wire reported that the star is inactive, while the system’s high-energy radiation remains relevant to questions about atmospheric survival.

On July 16, 2026, a Harvard-led team reported in Science that LHS 1140 b has a detected atmosphere. Earlier work by Cherubim and colleagues used WINERED, an instrument on the Magellan Clay Telescope at Las Campanas Observatory in Chile, to test a model of helium escaping from the planet’s upper atmosphere. During a September 2024 observing run, the team collected spectra as the planet crossed its star. The helium signal appeared before the planet’s disk crossed the star, which pointed to an extended stream of escaping gas ahead of the planet. Orbital Wire reported that the researchers ruled out interference from Earth’s atmosphere and stellar activity for that detection.

Energetic helium absorbs starlight at a near-infrared wavelength of 10,833 angstroms. The absorption is associated with a particular excited state of helium atoms, which can form after stellar radiation ionizes helium and the atoms recombine. This method can trace escaping gas from a planet; it is not a direct recording of the gas or a complete inventory of the atmosphere.

The study also places the result in the context of atmospheric loss. Its models favor an outflow driven by X-ray and extreme-ultraviolet radiation over core-powered mass loss, a competing process in which heat from within a planet helps drive atmospheric escape. That comparison concerns the models and the observed escape rate; it does not settle every question about the planet’s atmosphere.

What researchers need to check next

The authors say the proposed connection needs simultaneous near-infrared transit observations and measurements of stellar activity, including XUV flux. Gathering those measurements together would let researchers compare changes in the helium signal with the star’s high-energy output at the relevant time. The recommendation follows from the model comparison and the short-term X-ray variability detected in 2026.

The manuscript, identified as arXiv:2609.31859, was reported as being in second-round review at ApJL. Its conclusion should therefore be treated as a proposed explanation awaiting further testing, rather than a settled account of why helium escape varies.

Source: orbital-wire.com

First Signal (Original Mix)RIFT
F Minor
0:00/4:09